Top pick1$$Brick Fire Tavern
KaimukiยทPizza Restaurant
Neapolitan-style pizzas with local ingredients, plus Italian wine & cocktails, in a rustic space.
View details
Kaimuki punches well above its weight when it comes to pizza, and this list ranks the neighborhood's best by real visitor ratings submitted right here on NateEatsHawaii. Whether you're in the mood for wood-fired Neapolitan pies or a classic checkered-tablecloth slice, there's something on this street for every pizza lover.
Brick Fire Tavern tops the list, well-known for its Neapolitan-style pizzas made with local ingredients and paired with Italian wines and cocktails in a rustic setting. Further down the ranking, Kaimuki's Boston Pizza brings a homey, old-school vibe with Hawaiian topping options that give it a local flavor all its own.
All five spots are pulled from the roughly 1,900 Oahu restaurants cataloged on this site and ordered purely by the ratings real visitors have left. Keep an eye out for the NateEatsHawaii badge โ that marks the spots Nate has personally visited and recommends.
The ranking
Top pick1$$Neapolitan-style pizzas with local ingredients, plus Italian wine & cocktails, in a rustic space.
2$$Chain eatery serving up inventive pizzas, plus pastas & salads in a modern setting.
3$$
4$Homey, checkered-tablecloth spot for Boston-style pizza with Hawaiian topping options.
5$See every spot on a live map
Filter, get directions, and find what's open right now.
FAQ
Based on real visitor ratings on NateEatsHawaii, Brick Fire Tavern currently ranks #1 in Kaimuki, praised for its Neapolitan-style pizzas crafted with local ingredients in a rustic, welcoming space.
Kaimuki's Boston Pizza and Original Magoo's Pizza are both known as more casual, budget-friendly options in the neighborhood โ great for a no-fuss slice without a big bill.
The rankings update automatically as new visitor ratings come in on NateEatsHawaii, so the list always reflects the most current community feedback.