Top pick1$$'ili'ili Cash & Carry
Moiliili·Pizza Restaurant
View details
These are Oahu's top-rated pizza spots, ranked entirely by real visitor ratings collected right here on NateEatsHawaii — no editorial thumb on the scale. With 57 qualifying restaurants across the island, there's no shortage of great pie, whether you're craving a wood-fired Neapolitan in Waikiki, a classic East Coast-style slice from Boston's Pizza in Aiea, or a locally inspired creation at Brick Fire Tavern in Kaimuki.
The list spans everything from full-service Italian dining rooms like Appetito Craft Pizza & Wine Bar in Waikiki to no-frills neighborhood spots like Bob's Pizzeria in Kailua. Each one earned its ranking through the honest opinions of visitors who actually ate there.
Spots that Nate has personally visited are marked with the NateEatsHawaii badge on the page — a quick way to see which places have his firsthand stamp. Browse the full ranked list below to find your next favorite pizza on Oahu.
The ranking
Top pick1$$
2$A handful of tables fill this compact, no-nonsense spot for Italian staples like calzones & pasta.
3$$Full-service Italian restaurant with Neapolitan pizzas, wines, and cocktails in chic digs or outdoors.
4$$$Creative, elevated Italian dishes served in a polished restaurant that has a robust wine list.
5$$Casual spot with island flair offering creative pizzas, hearty sandwiches & desserts.
6
7
8$Homey, checkered-tablecloth spot for 19-inch, Boston-style pizza with fresh topping options.
9$$Neapolitan-style pizzas with local ingredients, plus Italian wine & cocktails, in a rustic space.
10$$Brick-oven pizzeria (part of a longtime local chain) with a broad menu, full bar & TVs.
11$$Pizza fare in Ala Moana. California Pizza Kitchen draws a steady crowd.
12$$Chain eatery serving up inventive pizzas, plus pastas & salads in a modern setting.
13$$Chain eatery serving up inventive pizzas, plus pastas & salads in a modern setting.
14$$Kid-friendly chain known for its arcade games, pizza parties & play zones.
15Unpretentious outpost dishing up vegan wood-fired pizzas in an alfresco setting.
16$$
17$$Lively, Irish-themed pub serving build-your-own, New York-style pizza, finger foods & craft beers.
18$$
19
20$Homey, checkered-tablecloth spot for Boston-style pizza with Hawaiian topping options.
21Kayak Cafe is a pizza spot in Ala Moana.
22$
23$$Airy, modern restaurant serving a European-influenced menu of sandwiches, flatbreads & macarons.
24
25Little G Cafe is a pizza spot in Ala Moana. Locals consider it a well-loved spot with takeout.
26
27
28$$
29$
30$Chain pizzeria serving oven-fired pies made with a diverse range of sauces, cheeses & toppings.
See every spot on a live map
Filter, get directions, and find what's open right now.
FAQ
'ili'ili Cash & Carry in Moiliili currently sits at the top of the rankings based on real visitor ratings on NateEatsHawaii. Rankings are updated as new reviews come in, so the list always reflects what diners are saying right now.
Casual spots like Big Kahuna's Pizza, Bob's Pizzeria in Kailua, and Boston's Pizza in Aiea are well-regarded for satisfying, no-fuss pizza without the fine-dining price tag. Brick Oven Pizza (part of a longtime local chain) is another solid, budget-friendly option worth checking out.
The rankings are based on live visitor ratings on NateEatsHawaii and update automatically as new ratings are submitted, so the list always reflects the most current consensus from real diners on the island.
Oahu